Top of Sidebar
Mission Statement
Do It Yourself Tips and Tricks
Books, Equipment, Software, and Training Reviews
Film Critiques
Community Section
Savings and Links
Editorials
Archives
Bottom of Sidebar
Back to the Home Page
Final Short Critique: A New Perspective, Pg. 2

When they get into the dynamic shooting in the skate parks, however, it looks like one of the pro editors from ESPN2's X-Games division took over. Here they're able to use the Brownstone Beam that Mr. Harris invented and get some pretty awesome shots. While the cameras aren't the best in the world, the way they are used and edited is top notch. For pure editing, there are lots of post strobes, slow-mos, and reversals that work very well for X-treme sports.

While the shooting is problematic
during the interview portions...
...the moving shots on the courses
are extremely nice.

Use of Audio
The audio for this short is quite good, which is amazing due to the fact that they were apparently using the on-board camera mic for the interviews with Jim Dellavalle. The music choices are fitting for the background of his interviews without getting overwhelming and the music chosen for his rides fits the arenas he is riding in.

There's even a nice bike collision where the music gets potted down and the loud crash comes through, followed by an admonition for Dellavalle not to hit the cameraman. After that, the music pops right back up and the sequence goes along nicely. I particularly like this because it uses what might have been a problem and turns it into a showcased feature, as though it had been intended.

There are a few times where sound effects and music clash, but it's pretty good for the most part. There is also the strange fact that profanity isn't bleeped out from the soundtrack, yet it is when Dellavalle uses the F-word later in the film.

Use of Budget
Pretty good use of budget, considering they traveled to three separate states on the eastern seaboard and had to get food for people. I assume that all the music is deferred in order to get it to come in at that low a cost.

Combinations of tightly edited
segments of precision and balance...
...and high flying stunts are where
this short gets extra rewatchability.

Lasting Appeal
While the lack of an ending and a rather ad-based feel do detract from lasting appeal, the fact that the stunts, camerawork, and editing are as good as they are makes this short interesting enough to rewatch and to show other people who are into X-treme sports.

Overall Comment
An unusual short that shows off the bike riding skills of Jim Dellavalle (& Friends) as well as the creative abilities of Mr. Harris' Brownstone Beam camera rig. In the end, it does a lot of things right, but greater forethought could have made it more satisfying and worthwhile.

 
Content            
      4.0         
Visual Look            
      8.5         
Use of Audio            
8.5         
Use of Budget            
7.0         
           Lasting Appeal            
           7.0         
Overall Score           
  7.0         

Mission | Tips & Tricks | Equipment & Software Reviews | Film Critiques
Groups & Community | Links & Savings
| Home


Contact Us Search Submit Films for Critique